Loam Farm: Cropping Changes

Like many real-life farms across the country, Andersons’ Loam Farm is also having to deal with the effects of the very wet autumn.  This has led to budgets for harvest 2020 being reworked to accommodate more spring planting.  Of the usual 300 hectares of wheat that this farm plants each autumn it has been assumed that half will not get in.  The farm is planning to grow 150 Ha of spring barley instead.  The resulting figures are shown in the table below – figures for the past two harvest are shown along with the pre-rain budget for 2020 and then the current one.

Loam Farm Model – source The Andersons Centre
£/Ha           Harvest Year –

2018*

2019‚~ 2020ƒ#

(Initial)

2020#ƒ

(Revised)

Output

1,205

1,237 1,217

1,094

Variable Costs

403

439 457

411

Gross Margin

802

798 760

683

Overheads

421

442 443

443

Rent & Finance

242

239 238

238

Drawings

79

79 79

79

Margin from Production

61

38 0

(77)

Basic Payment

228

230 219

220

Business Surplus

289

268 219

143

* result   ‚~ estimated   #ƒ budget

It can be seen that profitability was forecast to decline for the coming harvest anyway.  This was partly as a result of yields reverting to the mean after the wheat and beans produced higher-than-average figures for the previous harvest.  But costs were also projected to rise for the present cropping year.

With the farm now planning to grow a substantial area of spring barley, it can be seen that the overall output drops from the original budget as the revenue from the crop will not be as large as from winter wheat (despite some malting premium being assumed).  Output has also been reduced by the forecast oilseed rape yield being decreased – some of Loam Farm’s OSR crops are looking sickly in the wet ground.  Variable costs decrease as spring barley is a cheaper crop to grow.  No change has been made to overheads as it is assumed that cost structures will not change in the short-term.

Overall, the wet autumn means that profitability looks set to be reduced compared with initial estimates.  However, the change is not massive, which highlights the fact that spring crops don’t always affect overall performance too much if they are done well, simply because of how expensive it is becoming to grow winter crops.

Loam Farm is a notional business, located in East Anglia, which has been running since 1991 and tracks the fortunes of arable farming.  It comprises a 600 hectare (1,480 acre) combinable crop farm running a usual rotation of milling wheat, WOSR, feed wheat, and spring beans.  Of the cropped area, 240 Ha are owned and 360 Ha rented on FBTs.  There is a working proprietor plus one full-time man and harvest casual.

Potato Roundup

The wet October has frustrated potato lifting, with some growers still expecting to be harvesting at the end of November when crops will be vulnerable to more rain or frosts.

Early season conditions in the east of the country were, if anything, a little dry, while crops in the west and north of the country have had too much rain throughout the season.  The poor weather will lead to pressure on potato supply for the second year running and prices are starting to increase sharply already and are expected to rise throughout the season.

The AHDB estimates that 2019 GB plantings are just shy of 119,000 hectares, up only marginally on the 2018 figure.  Yields are likely to be below the long-term average and it is unlikely that a national crop of more than 5.2 million tonnes will be delivered.  The wet harvest will mean that good quality material will be in particular demand.

The European crop suffered from drought and heat in the first part of the season which damaged yields and made early harvesting difficult.  Heavy rain in the last six weeks has now delayed lifting and a significant shortage is likely.  This is supporting prices and demand for imported potatoes.

The UK has benefitted from EU import demand over the last year, particularly from Poland.  Exporters feared that a No-Deal Brexit would bring trade to a halt because, after departure, the UK would be treated as a third country supplier without EU export certification.  It was unknown as to how long it would take for the UK to gain certification.  However, sales of around 20,000 tonnes to the Canary Islands would have been protected by a separate arrangement as would seed potato exports to Egypt and Morocco, which have agreed to recognise the UK’s export status even outside the EU.

October Arable Commentary

This time last year, we discussed how well the planted crops had established and were growing.  This year, over much of the UK, there is little to talk about as many farms have done very little drilling at all.  Official data reports that England averaged 107.5 mm rainfall in September.  This reading is far lower than that recorded in some people’s rain gauges; the topic of conversation that has trumped the crop yield discussion in pubs in all arable parts of the country of late.  However, the last time the official September rainfall eclipsed 100mm was in 2000.  That year was even wetter therefore than infamous 2012 year, which, whilst it had been wet on and off since April, and became very wet in October to December, had a dryish September.  Notably, the average September rainfall across all of England is 64mm, just over half of what the country has received this season.  Wales has just had its wettest September since 1981 but Scotland had the driest September in four years this year.  October seems to have been similar.

Drilling therefore is considerably behind schedule, with several people cancelling winter varieties in favour of either fallowing or a determination to drill in the spring.  Others have adopted a wait-and-see approach with late-planted winter wheats still an option.  Any rotation changes driven by the weather will add to existing trends.  This is particularly the case with oilseed rape where the fall in planted area is expected to continue for harvest 2020.  The 2019 crop showed the smallest crop output since 2004, and the smallest planted oilseed rape area since 2002 (at which point there was industrial oilseed rape on set-aside land).

UK wheat prices have also remained uninspiring this month.  Since the UK nearby wheat futures contract slipped below the Chicago wheat price (Soft Red Winter) in June, it has shown no inclination to swap back, instead following a relatively close £15 per tonne premium over Chicago number 2 maize. Number 2 maize is the cheapest, commodity-level maize that is used for animal feed, starch production and other industrial uses, so we would expect our wheat to be worth a bit more than that!

Malting barley prices have risen slightly this month, but looking forward, if this year is going to be anything like other very wet autumns, we could have high areas of spring barley planted, meaning a thumping big pile of malting barley so very small premiums next harvest.  Growers should consider their marketing options such as minimum prices, contracts and so on.

Whenever Sterling has risen in the month, we have seen pulse prices soften as would be expected.  It continues to remind us that the marginal tonne of a commodity is the one that sets the local prices.  We have had three years of higher grain prices because of a weak currency, but if we see a Brexit Deal happen this might change back.

Crop Areas and Yields

The UK has had a record-breaking cereals harvest in 2019.  According to provisional Defra estimates, the total crop was over 25 million tonnes – the highest in the last two decades, and possibly of all time.  It is thought to be 22% higher than the 2018 figure.  In contrast, the oilseed harvest is down 13% on the year and at its lowest level since 2004.

The figures come from the June 2019 Survey of Agriculture and Horticulture, showing planted areas in the UK for main crops, and also estimates for crop production.  The key results for the arable sector are summarised in the table below.  The data is provisional, with final results expected before the year end. Wales does not produce provisional results, so 2018 data has been carried forward to allow UK figures to be presented.

UK June Census and Crop Production – source Defra

Area – ‘000 Ha

2016

2017 2018 2019

Change 18 to 19

WHEAT

1,823

1,792 1,748 1,815

3.8%

Yield (tonnes per Ha)

7.9

8.3 7.8 9.0

15.7%

Production (‘000 tonnes)

14,383

14,837 13,555 16,283

20.1%

BARLEY

1,122

1,177 1,138 1,166

2.4%

WINTER BARLEY

439

423 387 452

16.9%

SPRING BARLEY

683

754 751 714

-5.0%

Yield (tonnes per Ha)

5.9

6.1 5.7 7.0

22.7%

Production (‘000 tonnes)

6,655

7,169 6,510 8,180

25.6%

OATS

141

161 171 182

6.1%

Yield (tonnes per Ha)

5.8

5.4 5.0 6.0

19.9%

Production (‘000 tonnes)

816

875 850 1,082

27.2%

OTHER CEREALS

45

52 49 52

6.0%

TOTAL CEREALS

3,132

3,182 3,106 3,214

3.4%

Production (‘000 tonnes)

21,967

22,999 21,085 25,712

21.9%

OILSEED RAPE

579

562 583 529

-9.2%

WINTER OSR

570

554 575 525

-8.8%

SPRING OSR

9

9 8 5

-43.4%

Yield (tonnes per Ha)

3.1

3.9 3.4 3.3

-4.2%

Production (‘000 tonnes)

1,775 2,167 2,012 1,750

-13.0%

LINSEED

27

26 25 15

-38.1%

SUGAR BEET

86

111 114 108

-5.6%

POTATOES

139

145 140 145

3.6%

FIELD BEANS

177

193 155 137

-11.4%

COMBINING PEAS

51

40 38 41

7.5%

MAIZE

194

197 221 226

2.3%

FALLOW

262 241 265 224

-15.4%

2019 data is provisional

The figures indicate that wheat production in the UK is 20% larger than in 2018.  This is a combination of a larger planted area (+4%) and much better average yields than last year (+16%).   Barley output has increased by even more, with production almost 26% higher year-on-year.  The area recovered after its slight fall in 2018, and yields were high.  A closer look at the split between winter and spring tells us that the winter crop area has dramatically increased from the low point seen last year to its highest planted area since 2003.

The oat area has continued its upward trend the last five years, with a good yielding harvest up nearly a fifth on last year at 6.0 tonnes to the hectare, resulting in the overall production of oats being up by more than a quarter at 27.2%.

The rise in the various cereal areas has been largely because of the decline in OSR plantings – as can be seen from the table, other break crops such as linseed, pulses or roots have hardly changed at all.  The UK oilseed rape area has fallen to its lowest level since 2002 and down 9.2% on 2018’s crop area.  With yields in 2019 nothing spectacular, overall output has dropped by 13% year-on-year.  Total UK OSR production is over a third lower than its recent high-point in 2011.  The lack of pest and disease control continues to cause problems in oilseed rape production, with anecdotal evidence that flea beetle has continued to be an issue this planting season, becoming more prevalent across the UK. 

As we have outlined in previous articles, the large amount of grain availability is weighing on cereals’ markets and has contributed to the slide in prices seen over the last few months.  Conversely, the relative scarcity of oilseed rape has helped support values.   This is probably not sufficient compensation though to generate a turn round in OSR plantings for next season, with another likely decline expected. 

 

GB Potato Area

As growers in England start to lift potatoes into store, the AHDB has updated the 2019 planted GB potato area.  The revised figure puts the area at 118,950 hectares, 1% higher than last year, although this still remains one of the lowest on record.  According to the AHDB the majority of the increase has been seen from smaller growers increasing their area and is likely to be due to last year’s higher prices.  A fuller analysis of the potato market will be included in next month’s Bulletin.

Combinable Crop Situation

Oilseed rape production in the EU has not been so low since the EU the EU expanded to 27  Member States.  The introduction of Croatia in 2013 had minimal impact on the OSR supply and demand tables, but Bulgaria and particularly Romania, which joined in 2007, account for about as much production as the UK does.  The crop this year is thought (for example by Coceral) to be about 12% to 13% lower than last year, and as much as 29% lower than the highest production year of 2014.  In fact, since then, four out of the five years have incurred declines in OSR crop size.

This means that this year, the EU (including the UK in this description) will be importing oilseed rape from elsewhere.  Some have suggested 6 million tonnes of will be required.  At the same time, regulations on importing biodiesel produced from palm oil is becoming more expensive with duties rising.  Additionally, the rise of crude oil prices following the attacks on Saudi refineries have also led to rises in vegetable oil markets.  These factors have come together to support oilseed rape prices in recent weeks on European markets.

In the meantime, Sterling has gaining strength by 5% against the Euro in the light of rising expectations of a Brexit deal since early August.  This has wiped out any gains in the UK OSR markets. This (relatively modest) currency shift demonstrates just how dominant the value of the Pound is on agricultural prices.  We have no influence on the value of Sterling and minimal ability to predict accurately.

Taking this logic a little further, it follows that as soon as a decision on the type of Brexit is reached, whether Deal, No Deal or even no-Brexit, the impact on the value of our currency will almost inevitably be instant and dramatic; probably far more than 5% in either direction, depending on outcome.  In the short term, the profitability of cereal farming post Brexit-decision will be led by currency shifts.  Any other factors might be dwarfed by this one thing.

Exporters have been working round the clock to export as much wheat and barley from the UK’s exportable surplus since harvest.  Their deadline is 31st October as they do not know what the tariff rates will be after then.  Conveniently, there has been considerable buying interest from many of the large cereal buyers, mainly in North Africa including Algeria, Tunisia and Egypt.  These countries don’t buy from the UK, but they have occupied other exporters’ minds whilst UK traders have focused on our traditional Iberian markets.  This has helped UK grain prices to hold up, in the face of stronger Pound (see above).  Yet the EU wheat crop is considerably higher than last year and the US cereals prices (especially maize) have been falling this month.  The urgency of exporters to get stocks off farms and onto boats has supported prices.

Bean prices are also holding up well.  The urgency to export the (considerable) surplus is smaller, both as much of the bean export goes outside the EU anyway, and also as the tariff rate to the EU is far smaller.  In any case, the trade has struggled this year to find much that is of food grade, most ending up in feed bins.

Beet Price 2020

The beet price for the 2020 crop will be £19.60 per tonne.  This compares to the current price of £19.07.  Similar to the 2019 crop price, this has no crown tare deduction and is paid on the current sugar content payment scale; this is equivalent to a price of £20.99 per tonne on a crowned basis.  NFU Sugar and British Sugar have also announced the three year contract offer for 2020-2022.  This has been set at £20.45 per tonne, again with no crown tare deduction.  This is equivalent to a price paid on a crowned basis of £21.90 per tonne in year one and £21.18 per tonne in years two and three.

There will be a bonus mechanism for growers under both contracts; this triggers if the EU-reference price for white sugar reaches a certain price.  For the one-year contract the ‘threshold’ remains at €375 (reduced from €475 in 2019), growers will receive a 15% share of the price above that level.  The threshold for the three year contract will be €400.  If the EU-reference reaches this level, growers under the three year contract will receive a 25% share of the price above the threshold.  Other points which have been agreed include:

  • Market bonuses will be paid in two instalments (if they are triggered).  The first will be paid as soon as the beet volumes have been finalised
  • The paid mileage cap at Newark will reduce to 55 miles in 2021 and 50 miles in 2022.  For all the other factories it will remain at 60 miles.

Growers will have received a letter outlining the above information.  Contract offer documents will be posted out to during the end of September and the beginning of October.

Glyphosate

Germany looks set to ban the use of Glyphosate by the end of 2023 when the EU’s current approval for the chemical’s use expires.  Reports suggest it will start phasing out the world’s most widely-used herbicide from 2020, initially with a ban on domestic use and in parklands.  The decision comes after Austria announced a total ban in July; the first EU Member State to end the use of the chemical completely. Germany’s decision to phase-out the use of the weedkiller is due to claims it is a contributing factor to a decline in pollinating insect numbers and concerns it can cause cancer in humans.  The German-owned company Bayer who acquired Monsanto, the creator of Glyphosate, argue the chemical can be used safely and that it is ‘an important tool for ensuring the sustainability and production of agriculture’.

Arable Roundup

UK Harvest

Until the last week of August, harvest was a headache for many farmers.  Many areas had four inches of rain in June, another four in July and about 2.5 in August, meaning the ground was soft.  Intermittent showers meant progress was slow.  However, the last few days have been all-systems go, facilitating a catch-up.  The warm, dry, weather has also meant producers have been far less dependent on the drier than at the start of the harvest.

With a majority of cereals now cut, yields have been good to excellent overall.  Winter barley has yielded higher than average with plenty of our clients reporting 8 to 8.5 tonnes per hectare (3.25-3.5t per acre).  Wheat has also been very good.  Strong loam soils that have been cared for with ample organic matter over the years and heavy land have achieved in excess of 11 tonnes per hectare (4½ t per acre) – and not just in isolated cases.  Bushel weights of 80+ have been commonplace too, but Hagberg readings have not been as good following the intermittent rain-shine weather.  Lighter soils and those with less organic matter have been affected by the dry weather in May and early June.  However, yields are still good so plenty of light land farmers are recording above average results.  Oats are still in the field and losing colour so possibly less attractive for milling.

OSR has been variable because a fair area had larvae feeding on plants in spring which led to poor podding in crops.  That led to yields being moderate at best, many reporting around the 3-3.3 tonnes per Ha (1.2-1.3t per acre).

Beans have been at high risk of bleaching following the showery weather of the previous few weeks.  Beans discolour and therefore lose value easily and quickly.  Those that have managed to harvest beetle-free and coloured beans could expect a £25 to £30 premium over feed beans but the large amount of feed means this base price is not great.

European Harvest

Cereals harvests are completed in most part of the EU, including France and further South.  They are near completion in Northern Germany and Poland, and well underway in Eire, Denmark, Scandinavia and Baltic States.  Again, yields have been bumper.  For soft wheat, Strategie Grains, an analyst company forecast European production at 143 Mt, a considerable 12.3% increase on last year.  The wheat area is up by ¾ million hectares and yields are also above the 5-year average.

In France, the wheat crop will be high at 38 to 40 million tonnes depending on whom you ask.  Only one Department has recorded lower than average yields and proteins are high.  The German and Polish crops are also good.  Even outside the EU, the Ukrainians have also had high yields, and have already started their export campaign in earnest, with higher sales than last year and a target of 21 million tonnes, which is 5.5 million more than last year.

The EU is likely to have cut over 60 million tonnes of barley this year, mostly winters.  France will have seen a rise in springs because of oilseed rape problems.

Prices

This means there will be a large EU crop this year and nearby neighbours also providing surpluses. Achieving exports from the UK might prove tricky.  This explains why futures prices have hit contract lows in all positions in the last couple of weeks; we have lots to sell, everybody else who exports does too and those who import also have more grain than usual.  It is clear what this might mean to prices, especially when the possibility of having tariffs looms over the UK crops.  It is perhaps therefore no surprise that wheat values have fallen by £20 since June and £10 per tonne solely in August.

The weakening Pound has done little to retain any kind of value in commodities, in fact, comparing the UK Nearby wheat futures contract prices with the comparable French, a gap has opened up of about £10 per tonne more than usual. This might be the Brexit effect.