Beet Price Delay

In last month’s Bulletin we wrote that the beet price for the 2020 crop was still to be agreed.  The two parties, British Sugar and the NFU, are still deadlocked and it is reported it could be another month before the price is announced.  This is difficult for growers with the autumn planting season upon them; they are having to make decisions about how much ground to leave for spring beet drilling without knowing the price.  BS and the NFU have agreed a one-year contract price that is above this season’s  level (£20.42 per tonne).  However, the sticking-point is the value for a 3-year contract.

Metaldehyde Ban Overturned

The decision by Defra to ban Metaldehyde  slug pellets has been overturned by the High Court.  Michael Gove announced the ban back in December 2018 (see December’s article), saying the pesticide would be phased out over 18 months.  But a challenge by Chiltern Farm Chemicals into the legality of the way in which the decision to ban Metaldehyde by Defra was undertaken has been declared unlawful by the Court.  In fact before the hearing was due to take place the government conceded that its decision-making process had been flawed.

Defra is now required to decide whether to grant re-authorisation for the products or to revoke the existing authorisations.  For users, Metaldehyde slug pellets are expected to be available again with immediate effect.

UK Grain Harvest and Marketing Commentary

UK Combinable Crop Harvest – What Should We Expect?

The harvest is in its early stages; it started a little earlier than usual and for some, even earlier than last year.  Considerable activity until Thursday last week was seen with barley, oilseed rape and even some wheat reaching the barns, but the storms over the weekend have halted most harvesting. We expect a picture of a stuck combine in Friday’s Farmers Weekly as usual!

For much of the UK though, the crops are in a good condition, especially the cereal combinable crops and early indications suggest good yields (albeit early). The jury is still out for oilseed rape, although, whilst we have heard a lot about crop write offs and poor condition crops, there are still plenty of farmers sitting quietly on what looks like a full field of seeds. It is difficult to tell before the combine has been through. The storm over the weekend has flattened some crops at a very late stage which might cause some harvesting problems.

In much of Europe, particularly, France and Germany, the two main grain producing countries, the recent spells of very high temperatures have apparently taken a toll on the ripening crops. However, the crop tonnages forecast remain comfortably above the very poor yields harvested last year.

OSR

Oilseed rape harvest started before the storm.  Following the last couple of very dry days of last week, a few farmers had been harvesting very early in the day or trying to wet the seeds to a level that would be accepted by merchants. To recap, the standard FOSFA contract for oilseed rape is for 9% moisture.  Oilseed rape is not accepted at moisture levels above 10% (or you would incur drying charges).  You gain 1% in price for every 1% the moisture decreases to 6%.  Below that point, it becomes difficult for a crusher to extract oils so is rejected. If you are testing the seed and the moisture levels are heading down towards 6%, advice is to stop harvesting, and restart early in the morning (better than late in the evening because the moisture may have reached the seed rather than just the pod). Wetting oilseed rape is not recommended, as it is often uneven, rather, mix it with some wetter seed to make an average moisture within the tight band.

 Cereals

The barley harvest too is under way. It is early days and the better yields are always reported first so we reserve our judgement for a month. Barley harvest in France is a quarter through and moving northwards quickly. The very first wheat crops are starting to be cut now too, but it is too early to make any useful comments about it.  More next month.

Globally

Most combinable cereals are grown in the Northern Hemisphere, so our harvest time will be more or less in line with most others’. Across the EU, harvest is quickly moving northwards, with considerably better results than the poor yields from last year. The Black Sea region and Ukraine are also harvesting, with yields up on last season, although the Russian harvest is smaller than initially projected.  North America, the main breadbasket of the grain exporting world is wading through its winter wheat harvest, now being three quarters completed and in China, another large crop is being gathered.

Within a month, the analysts will start publishing their expectations of crop sizes, based not on planted area and trend yields, but more on actual reports coming in from the fields.

This all sounds rather bearish, and often is for a short period, whilst buyers identify what is available, in terms of quality, quantity and location. The calculators then come out and the premiums are established. We note that as the population continues to rise, the overall demand for grains is also increasing every year, and so to simply stand still, the world needs to harvest a record crop each year.

Marketing

When it comes to marketing our combinable crops this year, we should be more focused on the impacts of a Boris Brexit than the actual marketplace itself. Yes, we acknowledge we made similar comments following last season’s harvest and nothing happened, but there is still a chance that Brexit will actually occur, and more importantly, that it might do so without a deal.

Those with combinable crops to sell are reminded that exporters are not able to book sales to the EU post-Brexit day, because they do not know what the price will be (tariffs or no tariffs), so grain long-holders (farmers) should consider the risks and benefits of holding grain unsold into the autumn. Bear in mind that oilseeds have no tariffs so should not be affected by them, beans have only a low tariff and are mostly exported to non-EU destinations so should be similarly unaffected. However, the cereals are potentially holding a lot of value at the moment because the tariff structure protects them. We will probably have a surplus of feed wheat and oats this year so it might be prudent to pass the risk of these crops elsewhere sooner rather than later (i.e. selling them).

IGC Global Crop Predictions

As the northern hemisphere harvest gets underway, the forecasts for global grain output should become more accurate.  The International Grains Council (IGC) released an updated forecast at the end of July which is summarised in the table below.

Wheat stocks are expected to rise according to the IGC to levels of 2018/19, or in terms of stocks as a proportion of usage, no real change from last year.  However, from last month to this, the harvest expectations have declined slightly, making the stock level more akin to last year. A fall of 5 million tonnes from one month to another sounds like quite a lot but at this time of year when the crop is being gathered, it is minimal and of little impact to prices.  Consumers are comfortable at the moment that stocks will be available for them of the quality and specification they require.

The same cannot be exactly said of maize, with production thought 35 million tonnes lower than last year; back to the level seen for harvest 2017.  Consumption continues to go up each year, so stocks as a proportion of usage are forecast lower than previous years.  The IGC has the stock level falling from 322 million tonnes to 273 million, a decline of nearly 50 million tonnes, or in terms of requirement, from 28% of a year’s requirement to less than 24%.  This was already seen in June, but as we enter harvest, the figures will become more reliable.  Whilst this is a more dramatic fall of stock and supply level than wheat, it is still not at a level that is making the consumers frantic.

Soya production is though unlikely to be as high as last year, also being closer to the previous year, but with consumption gradually rising each year, stocks are seen falling from 15.6% to 12.3%; potentially bullish for the oilseed (and protein) price matrix.

Plant Protection Products

The removal of Plant Protection Products (PPPs) would see the average household food and non-alcoholic drinks bill increase by more than 17% according to a report commissioned by the Crop Protection Association.  The report, written by Sean Rickard, which looks at the effect the removal of PPPs would have on consumers’ expenditure on food and drink, also found the percentage increased further for households with children, pensioners, or poorer households.  In addition the report found that some of the largest increases in prices, due to the removal of PPPs, would be for fruit and vegetables, with the report stating  prices for these items would rise by at least 40%, presenting a serious challenge to healthy eating.  The full report can be found at https://cropprotection.org.uk/media/1153/sean-rickard-food-prices-report-final.pdf

 

AHDB Planting Survey

Confirming earlier predictions, the area of wheat and winter barley have risen for harvest 2019, whilst spring barley and, particularly, oilseed rape areas have dropped.  These findings come from the AHDB Planting Survey for 2019.  The table below summarises the key results.

Planting Survey– source AHDB
‘000 Ha – GB

2017       Final

2018     Final 2019 Estimate

% Change 18-19

Wheat

1,783

1,741 1,802

+4%

Winter Barley

416

381 422

+11%

Spring Barley

740

737 708

-4%

Oats ②

154

169 183

+8%

Cereals Total

3,097 3,027 3,115

+1%

Oilseed Rape ②

562

583 519

-11%

Total

3,659

3,610 3,634

+1%

① excludes ‘other cereals’ such as rye, triticale etc. ② OSR and oats figures for Wales not available yet (they were both 5,000 Ha in 2018 and these amounts have been included in the table)

The standout figure is the 12% drop in the oilseed rape area in Great Britain.  This is rather higher than the figure seen in the AHDB’s Early Bird Survey (see December Bulletin), indicating that some crops may have been written-off between planting and harvest due to poor establishment and pest issues.  The South East of England saw the largest drop in area, with 23% less OSR than last year.  However, there were falls in every GB region apart from the North East of England – even those areas in the north and west that, anecdotally, have suffered less from flea beetle than southern parts.

With the benign sowing conditions in the autumn, it is perhaps not surprising that the area of winter cereals has risen – farmers tend to keep planting whilst the ‘going is good’.

The survey also looks at cereals varieties planted.  The chart below shows trends in wheat Groups over the pat ten years.  In terms of barley, the survey found that 56% of the crop (both winter and spring) is varieties with malting potential.

 

Sugar Beet Crop

British Sugar expects the 2019 beet harvest to ‘at least’ match that of 2018 in terms of tonnage.  In a trading update, released by its parent company ABF, the processor stated that this year’s planted area was 7% lower at just over 102,000 hectares.  However, this drop would be more than offset by higher yields resulting from good growing conditions.  Last year average yields dipped to 69 tonnes per Ha due to late sowings and the summer drought.  The 2019 crop looks set to surpass that, but it is too early to say whether it will get close to the record 83.4 tonnes per Ha seen in 2017.  Traditionally, this would be the time of year when the price for the next year’s beet crop would be announced (i.e. the 2020 crop).  However, the timing has slipped recently, with the price announcement last year being made in September.  This may again be the case.  With EU and global sugar markets still in the doldrums, growers should perhaps not expect too much of an uplift on 2019 crop prices. 

Potato Update

A larger potato crop than last year is on the cards, but the lack of any carry-over is likely to keep the market tight and support prices, writes Cedric Porter of World Potato Markets.

The AHDB’s first estimate for the 2019 crop kept the area virtually unchanged from last year at 118,000 hectares, the third smallest ever; although only 100 hectares less than in 2018.  A five-year average yield of 46.6 tonnes per hectare would result in a crop of 5.5 million tonnes, 11.6% more than last year, but still the seventh smallest on record.

A 5.5 million-tonne crop would keep the market in balance.  The 4.925 million-tonne 2018 crop has effectively had to last just 10 months because the 2017 crop was so large it was still being used well into September.  Stocks from the 2018 crop will be largely cleared by the end of July this year.  This means that there will be demand for the 2019 maincrop as soon as it comes out of the ground, and stocks may have to last until late August next year when the first of the 2020 maincrop is lifted.  Thus, the 2019 crop would have to last at least 12 months, if not 13 months.

A 10-month season meant the 2018 crop was used at an average rate of 492,500 tonnes a month.  If there is a 12-month season, a 5.5 million tonne crop would only provide 458,300 tonnes a month and a 13-month season would only cover demand of 423,000 tonnes.  Even a 5.8 million tonne crop would only cover demand of 483,300 tonnes.

One factor that could impact on the coming season is the UK’s ability to export ware potatoes.  Strong end-of-season demand from Eastern Europe means that 2018/19 exports are likely to be well over 200,000 tonnes; outstripping imports by more than 50,000 tonnes.  A larger EU harvest may stifle that demand, and there is also the prospect that a No-Deal Brexit could prevent the UK from shipping potatoes to the EU entirely because certification for the UK as a third-country supplier is not in place.

Old crop prices rallied at the end of the season, partly driven by increased export demand.  The AHDB average free-buy is now at £242 per tonne, which compares to a season high of £273 per tonne in December and a low of £211 per tonne in early May.  Early 2019 crop prices have remained relatively stable but are slipping as supply increases.

It has been confirmed that the 2019/20 season will be the last when anti-sprouting chemical CIPC can be used after an EU ban. Growers fear that very low MRLs (maximum residue levels) could mean future crops are contaminated from historic applications that have seeped into store walls.

Arable Market Thoughts

It never rains, it always pours!  By early June, some were concerned about the dry soil conditions, by the end, the concern was flooding.  Most of the crops that had been flattened have picked up, but not all, increasing the risks of Fusarium.  Combinable crops now require sunshine to help them ripen with good quality and bushel weights.

The other thing that has fallen over this month (which we had been warning would happen) is the premium that the old crop wheat carried over new crop.  Sooner or later the two crop prices have to merge, and they did this decisively in June.  In fact old crop long-holders will be feeling frustrated by the chart clearly showing July 2019 futures values in January of £180 now being worth £145.  Also, new crop wheat prices have taken a sharp turn upwards, now clearly ahead of old crop.  This will encourage any buyers to take short term cover and close the gap.  Farmer sellers with adequate storage might be tempted to carry the grain over if it is in satisfactory condition.

Globally, the wheat crop is overall healthy and abundant, with expectations from the International Grains Council that it will outstrip consumption to leave slightly higher stocks this coming season.  This has helped explain the price falls in the market.  Maize though, the main combinable crop in the world, is thought abundant but not likely to match annual demand, so stock levels are expected (by the IGC) to decline again this year.  This will be the third decline since 2016/17 from 363 to 284 million tonnes; a substantial fall.

Soybean stocks are also thought likely to return a small decline in physical stock level after the 2019/20 season, although only by 1 million tonnes.  This is a tiny change after such a sharp rise in stock from 25 million tonnes to the current 53 million in only six years.  The question of how much oilseed rape will be grown in the UK is concerning many; whilst we have reported the poor OSR conditions on many farms this year, we have not pointed out that other arable farmers are quietly very happy with the condition of theirs. Some has been grubbed and replaced, other fields are looking excellent.

Bean crops are largely looking good throughout the country, and with new crop reaching good prices, perhaps now is the time to book some in.  Currently, we would expect bean crops to outperform their overall dismal performance from last year.

Crop Area Revision

Defra has reduced its figure for the 2018 harvest wheat crop by 49,000 hectares.  Many other crops have also seen revisions in their areas.

The changes have come about as a result of an investigation by Defra into the June Survey figures.  We reported in February that a large discrepancy had opened-up between the areas that the June Survey generated, and the figures from BPS claims in England.

Following investigation, Defra has found that some respondents to the Survey had provided data for their whole business rather than just for the ‘holding’ that they were asked for (a number of farming businesses comprise multiple holding numbers).  Once this was corrected for, the areas of most crops have fallen.  The table sets out revised figures for the main crops for the whole UK (although this revision only applies to England).

UK Crop Areas (June Survey) – source Defra
‘000 Ha

2015

2016 2017 2018 (old) 2018 (revised)

% revision

Wheat

1,832

1,823 1,792 1,797 1,748

-2.7%

Winter Barley

442

439 423 394 387

-1.8%

Spring Barley

659

683 754 763 751

-1.6%

Oilseed Rape

652

579 562 593 583

-1.7%

Fallow

214

262 241 270 265

-1.9%

For further details see – https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/report-on-the-revisions-to-the-june-survey-crop-areas

The Survey figures still do not completely match those from the BPS, which are generally lower.  Defra are satisfied that this is correct, as not all farms claim the BPS.  As part of the analysis, figures on the gradually declining number of BPS claimants, and claimed areas in England have been published.  It is interesting to see that the area claimed has declined by 3% in the three years 2015 to 2018.

BPS Claimants & Areas – source Defra

2015

2016 2017 2018

% change 2015-18

Number of Claimants

87,563 86,139 85,414 84,232

-3.8%

Claimed Area (‘000 Ha)

8,809

8,658 8,578 8,541

-3.0%